HomeAll tools · 中文
Policy X-Ray · Year-by-Year Surrender IRR

Insurance IRR Calculator: The Illustration Never Lies — The Missing IRR Does

Copy the cash-value table or annuity schedule from your policy illustration, and see the true annualized return of surrendering in every single year — computed on the spot.

Disclaimer: This tool is a cash-flow calculator and does not constitute insurance, savings, or investment advice. The demo templates use illustrative numbers for teaching purposes and do not represent any product on sale. Actual cash values and annuity payouts are governed solely by your policy contract and the insurer. Decisions on buying or surrendering should weigh the full contract terms and professional advice. Non-guaranteed benefits such as dividends and universal-life crediting rates are out of scope.

Step 1 · Start From a Template

Both templates are teaching examples (annual premium 100,000 × 10 years, issued at age 30) that show the cash-flow shape of each product family. Open one, then overwrite every cell with the numbers from your own policy.

Step 2 · Year-by-Year Cash Flows (Premium = money you pay in; Cash Value = what you get back if you surrender that year; Annuity = what you receive that year)

Tap a cell to edit; press Enter to jump to the next one. Add a year with the button below, delete a row with the × at its end. Data never leaves this device.

YearPremium Out (CNY)Year-End Cash Value (CNY)Annuity Received (CNY)
Surrender IRR by Year · Drag the Cursor for DetailsDashed line = cumulative premiums
IRR if you surrender that year (%) Cumulative premiums (right axis, 10k CNY)
Break-Even Year (Cash Value ≥ Premiums)
—
—
IRR at Break-Even
—
Annualized return the moment you break even
Hold-to-End IRR
—
The final row of the table
Deepest Underwater Gap
—
The year furthest from break-even during the lock-in
Total Premiums Paid
—
Sum of the premium column
Total Received
—
Annuity column total + final-year cash value

My Calculation Log

Stored only in this browser, so you can compare products and holding periods later. Entries keep the headline numbers only, never the full table.

Nothing yet — hit Save once the numbers look right.

What This Table Really Computes

Every policy illustration ships with a cash-value table: how much you would get back if you surrendered in each year. Yet the agent only shows you the far-right column — 1.65 million after 30 years — never that surrendering in year 3 burns half your money, and break-even only arrives in year 14. The IRR (internal rate of return) discounts every premium paid out and every yuan received back to the same point in time, giving the true annualized return of surrendering in that specific year. It is the only yardstick that compares savings-oriented life insurance, annuities, bank deposits, and government bonds on equal footing.

How this page works: from year 1 to year N you pay premiums (negative cash flows) and may receive annuity payouts (positive cash flows); assuming you surrender at the end of year t, you also collect that year cash value. Solving the IRR for every t and plotting them all draws the entire curve — you will see the deep pit of the lock-in period, the climb toward break-even, and the long plateau beyond.

What the Two Classic Curves Look Like

Savings-oriented whole life: early cash values sit far below premiums (deeply negative IRR), then climb after break-even and settle onto a long-term plateau near 2–3%. It is a tool for locking in a guaranteed long-term rate, not short-term savings.

Annuities: the accumulation phase digs a similar pit; once payouts begin, the cash value drops fast — sometimes to zero — and the surrender-basis IRR briefly dives (your money has been converted into lifelong income). But as payouts stretch on, the IRR climbs steadily. The longer you live, the better the deal — which is exactly how an annuity hedges longevity risk.

So always ask three questions: when is break-even? What is the IRR at break-even? What does the IRR reach if you hold to year X? These three numbers are far more honest than any total-return figure.

Assumptions and Boundaries

InputTemplate (whole life / annuity / blank) · per year: premium out · year-end cash value · annuity received
OutputSurrender-IRR curve by year · break-even year · IRR at break-even · hold-to-end IRR · deepest underwater gap · calculation log
DefaultWhole-life savings template on load (100,000 per year × 10 years, teaching example)
ProcessingAll computed locally in your browser; IRR solved by bisection to 0.01% annual precision; amounts handled in exact cents; data stored in localStorage and never uploaded
LengthMinimum 2, maximum 60 policy years
Known limitsExcludes non-guaranteed benefits (dividends, universal crediting), premium waivers, partial-surrender rules, policy loans, death benefits and taxes; cash flows are assumed as year-end lump sums

FAQ

Are the returns in a policy illustration real?
Illustration numbers usually blend guaranteed and projected components, and early cash values sit far below premiums paid. Laying out every year of cash flows (premiums negative, surrender values positive) and computing the IRR reveals a different annualized return for each surrender year — deeply negative in the first few years.
Why is my IRR negative tens of percent after paying for only two years?
Because surrendering returns only the cash value, which in the early years is often half of what you paid — or less. Losing tens of thousands over two years annualizes into negative tens of percent. That is not a calculation error; it is the real cost of the lock-in period, reminding you not to park money you will need soon.
Is an IRR just above 2% bad?
It depends on the alternative and the purpose. The 2–3% of savings-oriented whole life is contractually guaranteed for life and compounds later on; its real competitors are falling deposit rates and government bonds, not equity funds. It will not beat the long-run return of risk assets either — so fix the time horizon and purpose of the money first, then judge the IRR.
Why does the IRR dip right after annuity payouts start?
Once payouts begin, the cash value is rapidly consumed — sometimes to zero — so surrendering returns almost nothing and the surrender-basis IRR dives. Keep the policy and keep collecting, though, and the IRR climbs year after year. That is precisely the point: the value of an annuity lies in lifelong income, not in surrender. Both views are one tap away on this page.
Where do I find my policy numbers?
The cash-value table in your contract maps to the second column; if it is quoted per 1,000 of sum assured or per 10,000 of premium, convert it to whole-policy amounts first. The annuity or survival-benefit schedule maps to the third column. Dividends and universal-account projections are non-guaranteed and deliberately excluded — to see the guaranteed picture, enter only guaranteed items.