← HomeAll tools · 中文
Pension · two routes simulated to age 85

China pension or DIY investing? Two curves decide

The same money, two destinies, drawn side by side: one buys a lifelong state pension, the other compounds in index funds — drag the sliders and watch them cross.

⚠️ For reference only: this tool is a general estimate built on publicly announced policy, not social-insurance, tax or investment advice. The rule tables are a simplified model of the November 2026 publicbasis; policies and crediting rates may change. Funds carry risk and past returns do not guarantee the future — rely on your local social insurance bureau and qualified professionals for real decisions.

Step 1 · Your city and contribution tier (pension 20% + medical, all self-paid, flexible-employment basis)

The monthly contribution is auto-filled from your chosen city's 2026 contribution base — you can ignore it and head straight to the sliders below.

Step 2 · Drag these two sliders, curves redraw instantly

Your assumed annual investing return (compound)4.0%

Common long-run index expectations. 0% = cash, 4% = conservative, 6% = optimistic, 8%+ = historical high band (the future may not repeat it).

How long do you plan to live85yo

The pension pays for life: this slider is its biggest swing factor. At 62 one route runs away; at 95 the other does.

Two curves · unit: 10k CNYdrag sliders above to redraw
Pension route: cumulative benefits in retirement (never stops) DIY route: account balance, monthly compounding (empty = over)

The pension route

Monthly outlay—
Total contributed—
Monthly pension at 60—
Lifetime total (to chosen age)—
Personal account balance—
Internal rate of return—

The DIY investing route

Monthly investing (same budget)—
Principal invested—
Same withdrawal lasts until—
Balance at chosen age—
Account at retirement—
4%-rule monthly draw—

My scenario archive

Stored only in this browser, so you can compare how the verdict shifts across cities, tiers and return assumptions.

No scenarios yet — tune the sliders, then hit "Save".

What these two curves are really comparing

The pension route converts the same monthly outlay into two pieces: the basic pension, driven by the city's average wage at your retirement and your contribution years, and the personal-account pension, paid out as the account balance divided by 139 months (the divisor at retirement age 60). It pays until death — the structural difference from any financial asset.

The DIY route keeps every cent in your own account, compounding monthly, spendable and inheritable however you like — but it is a one-shot pool: when it empties, it is over, and nobody backstops your longevity risk.

So the real comparison is not "which total is bigger" but which cash-flow structure holds up better against a lifespan you cannot know in advance. That is why the lifespan slider is the protagonist of this page.

How the math works (full methodology)

Contributions: flexible-employment rate is pension 20% plus local medical; every city entry uses that city's published 2026 contribution-base floor and cap. Investing: monthly compounding, whole-month crediting, integer-cent accumulation — no floating-point drift. Pension: the retirement-year city average wage is extrapolated at 3% annual growth, and the personal account is credited at 3% (recent official crediting rates were higher; we take the conservative number).

IRR is solved by bisection over the monthly cash flows, then annualized, precise to 0.01%. Everything is computed live in your browser — it works offline.

Facts and boundaries

InputsCity (10) · tier (60/80/100%) · age 16-59 · years 5-25 · return 0-10% · lifespan 62-100
OutputsDual curves · key numbers per route (outlay, total, monthly income, IRR) · crossover banner · scenario archive
DefaultsChongqing 100% tier · age 30 · 15 years · 4% return · live to 85
ProcessingComputed locally in your browser (monthly compounding, integer cents); nothing uploaded; archive kept in localStorage
LimitsMax 25 contribution years (capped at age 60); max lifespan 100
Known gapsMedical-insurance value, funeral grants, annual pension indexation, inflation and taxes are not modeled; rules reflect the Nov 2026 public baseline, simplified

FAQ

Is paying into China social insurance worth it for freelancers?
It depends on two variables you cannot control: how long you live, and the returns you could earn yourself. The pension trades roughly a 6% long-term IRR for a lifelong monthly check — the longer you live, the better it gets. If you can reliably beat 6% a year and do not live unusually long, investing yourself wins. Drag both sliders and the crossover point on the curves will tell you.
Should I keep contributing after the 15-year minimum?
Each extra year adds another "city average wage × 1% × half your index" to the basic pension and one more compounding year to the personal account — but the marginal IRR slowly declines. Drag years from 15 to 20 to 25, watch how monthly income and IRR move, then weigh that against your own opportunity cost.
What should I put in the return slider?
There is no "correct" answer, only what you genuinely believe. The CSI 300 total-return index did roughly 8% annualized over two decades — with brutal drawdowns along the way; globally, 4-6% is the more commonly cited forward expectation for broad index funds. Try all three values and see which conclusion survives.
Isn't this model too simplified?
Yes, deliberately. Medical-insurance value, funeral and survivor benefits, annual pension raises (~3% recently) and inflation are not modeled — the first two favor the pension, the last one erodes both. Treat it as a structure comparator: read the shapes and the crossover, not any single absolute number.
What happens to my personal account if I die early?
The personal-account balance is inheritable by law; it is not confiscated. The basic pension stops at death (some cities pay a survivor grant). So the pension route is not a total loss in the early-death scenario, but it does take a heavy haircut — which is exactly why the lifespan slider exists.