Stop-Loss Expectancy Checker: what do your parameters really change?
Six sliders define your trading rules, and Monte Carlo simulates tens of thousands of price paths to deliver expectancy, stop-out rate and confidence intervals on the spot - plus three charts revealing a counterintuitive truth.
⚠️ For learning and simulation only: This tool uses a random model for teaching, not investment advice. The simulation uses random numbers and simplifying assumptions (geometric Brownian motion, fixed parameters, close-based triggers), not live trading and not a forecast of real markets. Real markets have gaps, slippage, liquidity and fee differences. Decide independently and consult a professional.
Step 1 · Set your trading rules
Stop-loss size5.0%
Exit at a loss when price falls this far below entry
Daily standard deviation of price; higher means bumpier paths
Daily drift (trend)0.00%
Average daily move; 0 = zero drift (no edge)
Round-trip cost0.10%
Combined fees and slippage for entry and exit
Number of simulated paths
Checkup result · expectancy per trade
Simulating...
Move the sliders and tap Run checkup to get an answer from tens of thousands of paths.
Geometric expectancy
—
Compound basis, long-run growth
95% confidence interval
—
Spread of single-trade returns
Stop-out rate
—
Share hitting the stop first
Take-profit rate
—
Share hitting the target first
Expiry close rate
—
Share reaching expiry untouched
Arithmetic expectancy
—
Simple average, lifted by big winners
Sampled paths by outcome: red = target first · green = stop first · grey = held to expiry.
My parameter experiments
Compare results across parameter sets to see whether tightening the stop really changes expectancy. Stored only on this device.
No records yet - run a checkup, then tap Save parameters.
A counterintuitive question
Many believe that tightening a stop protects capital and boosts returns. But in a trendless (zero-drift) random market, the stop only decides how often and at what size you exit - it creates no return.
Tighten it and you leave more often with small losses, and may lock in small wins sooner. The shape of each trade changes, but overall geometric expectancy barely moves (net of trading costs). That is the origin of the name zero drift: the water level does not rise just because you move the cup around.
What the three charts say
Price paths: a proportional sample of price paths. Red hits the upper bound (target) first, green hits the lower bound (stop) first, grey touches neither. The green ones were not wrong forecasts - under zero drift, which bound comes first is largely down to the path's own randomness.
Stop sweep: holding everything else fixed, the stop is swept from 1% to 20% and geometric expectancy is plotted against it. It is basically a flat line near zero, pushed negative by costs - moving the stop does not systematically lift expectancy.
Return distribution: a histogram of single-trade returns. It often shows the asymmetry of "many small wins, fewer larger losses" - the typical fingerprint of a take-profit/stop-loss system.
Basis and limits
Model
Geometric Brownian Motion (GBM) price paths advanced daily; close price decides whether a bound is hit
Inputs
Stop size · reward-risk ratio · max hold · daily volatility · daily drift · round-trip cost · path count (2k/20k)
Exponential of the mean log return, measuring compound growth; arithmetic is the simple average
Limits
No gaps, slippage detail, intraday trigger order, money management or position sizing; fixed parameters; simulation is not live trading
Purpose
Teaching simulation to build intuition about stops and expectancy; not investment advice
Common questions
Why doesn't tightening my stop raise expectancy?
Under a random walk, the stop only sets the size at which you exit. Tightening it raises exit frequency and changes each trade's win/loss size, and the two offset. What truly lifts expectancy is positive drift (an actual edge) or lower costs, not moving the stop line. Slide daily drift into positive territory and you will see expectancy rise.
Why do geometric and arithmetic expectancy differ?
Arithmetic expectancy is the simple average and is pulled up by a few big winners; geometric expectancy uses the log average, reflecting real compounding across consecutive trades. When returns are volatile, geometric is markedly lower than arithmetic - that gap is volatility drag. For long-run survival, geometric is the more conservative and realistic figure.
Which colour is take-profit and which is stop-loss?
Following Chinese market convention, this tool uses red for take-profit (winning exit) and green for stop-loss (losing exit) - the opposite of Western colouring. Red paths hit the upper bound first, green paths the lower.
Can I use this simulation for live trading?
No. It is a teaching tool with a simplified random model and fixed parameters to build intuition. Real markets have gaps, slippage, liquidity, price limits and fee differences, and prices are not strictly a random walk. Do not make actual trading decisions from it.