站点名称:China Pension vs DIY Investing: Two Curves to Age 85 - 9314 Toolbox
所属分类:通用效率工具
相关标签: # China pension vs investing # flexible employment social insurance # China pension calculator # pension IRR # DIY pension # index fund retirement # freelancer retirement China # state pension worth it
官方网址:https://www.9314.cn/tools/jiao-she-bao-xuan-ding-tou/en/
进入网站站点介绍
Also available in full-screen. Here is how the comparison works.
Flexible-employment contributors in China pay both legs of the social insurance out of pocket — no employer splitting the bill. The pension route trades certain money for a lifelong monthly check: the basic pension scales with the city's average wage at your retirement, the personal account pays out over 139 months, and both continue until death. The DIY route trades the same money for a pool you fully control: monthly compounding, withdrawable anytime, inheritable balance — but when it empties, it is over, and nobody backstops your longevity risk.
The verdict does not hinge on the city or the tier. It hinges on two variables you cannot control: how long you live and the returns you could earn. Under this page's defaults (Chongqing, 100% tier, starting at 30, 15 years), the pension's long-run IRR is about 5.9% — at age 75 even a 4% index assumption beats it; at 95 the pension pulls ahead by a margin that stuns. Drag the lifespan slider from 62 to 100 and watch the crossover point travel — more convincing than any argument.
Contributions follow the pension 20% + medical flexible-employment basis with each city's published 2026 base. Investing compounds monthly in exact integer cents. The average wage is extrapolated at 3% growth, the personal account credited at 3% (a conservative pick). Not modeled: the insurance value of medical coverage, funeral grants, annual pension indexation, inflation — the first two favor the pension, the last erodes both. Use it as a structure comparator: read the shapes and the crossover, not any single absolute number.
Is paying into China social insurance worth it for freelancers? It depends on two variables you cannot control: how long you live, and the returns you could earn yourself. The pension trades roughly a 6% long-term IRR for a lifelong monthly check — the longer you live, the better it gets. If you can reliably beat 6% a year and do not live unusually long, investing yourself wins. Drag both sliders and the crossover point on the curves will tell you.
What should I put in the return slider? There is no "correct" answer, only what you genuinely believe. The CSI 300 total-return index did roughly 8% annualized over two decades — with brutal drawdowns along the way; globally, 4-6% is the more commonly cited forward expectation for broad index funds. Try all three values and see which conclusion survives.
Isn't this model too simplified? Yes, deliberately. Medical-insurance value, funeral and survivor benefits, annual pension raises (~3% recently) and inflation are not modeled — the first two favor the pension, the last one erodes both. Treat it as a structure comparator: read the shapes and the crossover, not any single absolute number.
What happens to my personal account if I die early? The personal-account balance is inheritable by law; it is not confiscated. The basic pension stops at death (some cities pay a survivor grant). So the pension route is not a total loss in the early-death scenario, but it does take a heavy haircut — which is exactly why the lifespan slider exists.
中文版:https://www.9314.cn/tools/jiao-she-bao-xuan-ding-tou/
评论列表 (0条)